Comparing HF Wire Antennas for NVIS

Continuing our look at how to make the most of simple wire antennas I am using EZNEC to compare the performance of a wire dipole antenna in various configurations. The goal here continues to be a simple to deploy antenna usable on the road for VAQP Expedition. Our initial focus will be a 40 meter half-wave design. Then we will compare this with other possible antenna geometries and also investigate whether adding a wire on or near the ground beneath the antenna helps radiate more power skyward. The baseline configuration will look like this…

40 Meter Inverted V

This is an inverted V with the apex over 26 feet high and the ends pulled to about 3 feet above ground resulting in each element at a 45 degree angle.

I used EZNEC+ with this EZNEC File.

The ground is set to ‘real’ and ‘high accuracy’ with the default conductivity.

The broadside elevation pattern for 7100kHz looks great for NVIS…

Elevation pattern of 40 meter Inverted V

The simulation suggests the gain straight up is a modest 2.8dBi, but the 3dB half-power angles are very wide. For comparison, the elevation pattern inline with the antenna looks like…

40 Meter Inverted V Inline Pattern

The half power angles are less, but this is really quite good for NVIS. The NASCAR drive-on stand and WonderPole flag pole would be a perfect way to achieve this antenna. The antenna wires can be part of the guying system. This antenna should set up in minutes and perform almost as good as a home station.

Using the above baseline antenna we will compare it with the following possibilities…

At the end of this series of articles we will summarize the results and look for a clear winning topology.

One Response to “Comparing HF Wire Antennas for NVIS”

  1. Eldon Richardson on August 21st, 2009 at 202 UTC

    Would like to see which is the best for NVIS antenna! I can not find the endo of this article!!

    73s
    Eldon, W4IOS

Leave a Reply